Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2018 Issue: Editor's Note and Table of Contents

Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2018 Issue: Editor's Note and Table of Contents

Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2018 Issue: Editor's Note and Table of Contents

By : ASJ Editors

ARAB STUDIES JOURNAL
VOL. XVI, NO. 1
Fall 2018 

 


We are proud to feature a collection of pieces that innovate new methodological approaches, confront the relationship between knowledge and power, and speak to the urgent concerns of the present, infrastructure, ecology, migration, and war. In “Epicures and Experts: The Drinking Water Controversy in British Colonial Cairo,” Shehab Ismail explores taste, class, and the environment. When in 1905 the Cairo Water Company altered its source of intake to deep wells instead of the Nile, it pitted experts, officials, and the urban poor in a battle over knowledge, medical traditions, and water practices. In tracing the five-year struggle in which the palate became a battleground, Ismail reveals how taste, as a mode of embodied knowledge became a site of confrontation between heterogenous epistemic persuasions. In “From Mandate Borders to the Diaspora: Rashaya’s Transnational Suffering and the Making of Lebanon in 1925,” Reem Bailony traces debates on the social, political, and economic constructions of Lebanon and Syria, both in the borders of the French Mandate and well outside of it. By placing mahjar studies and Middle East studies in close conversation, Bailony both calls for and provides a model for a methodology that transgresses the territorial confines of the nation-state. In doing so, she reveals the crucial role of the mahjar in consolidating Lebanon as nation- ally distinct from Syria and in need of different sectarian arrangements. Neha Vora and Ahmed Kanna contribute reflections on two decades of ethnographic experiences researching Dubai and other cities in the Arabian Penninsula. “De-exceptionalizing the Field: Anthropological Reflections on Migration, Labor, and Identity in Dubai,” explores and critiques scholarly identity and authority in a call to develop understandings of Gulf cities that address migration, diaspora, place, and belonging. Vora and Kanna thus put the individual experiences of politics, geography, racialization, and minoritization into conversation with the knowledge that is produced on these historical forces. Graham Pitts reveals how the “human ecology” of Lebanon evolved according to the logic of an expanding and retracting global capitalism in “The Ecology of Migration: Remittances in World War I Mount Lebanon.” In detailing the material and environmental history of migration as well as highlighting World War I, the famine, and remittances, Pitts traces a broader trajectory of Lebanon’s history. In “Writing Shame in Asad’s Syria,” Judith Naeff analyzes how the Syrian author Khaled Khalifa built feelings of shame into the literary structure of his novel No Knives in the Kitchens of this City. She traces the multiple forms of shame and how, like rot, its pervasive spread unravels relations. Shame, she suggests, is at once contagious and repulsive, and is one site to both reflect on and understand the unraveling of Syrian social landscapes under the Asads’ authoritarianism. We offer as always a robust set of reviews and review essays that feature the latest contributions to the study of the Middle East. 


T A B L E    O F     C O N T E N T S

Articles

 
8. Epicures and Experts: The Drinking Water Controversy in British Colonial Cairo
Shehab Ismail
 
44. From Mandate Borders to the Diaspora: Rashaya's Transnational Suffering and the Making of Lebanon in 1925
Reem Bailony
 
74. De-Exceptionalizing the Field: Anthropological Reflections on Migration, Labor, and Identity in Dubai
Neha Vora and Ahmed Kanna
 
102. The Ecology of Migration: Remittances in World War I Mount Lebanon
Graham Auman Pitts
 
130. Writing Shame in Asad’s Syria
Judith Naeff
 

Reviews

 
150. Citizen Strangers: Palestinians and the Birth of Israel’s Liberal Settler State by Shira Robinson
Reviewed by Maha Nassar
 
155. Lineages of Revolt: Issues of Contemporary Capitalism in the Middle East by Adam Hanieh 
Reviewed by Benoit Challand
 
160. Qatar: Securing the Global Ambitions of a City-State by David B. Roberts 
Reviewed by Jocelyn Sage Mitchell
 
164. The Ottoman Scramble for Africa by Mostafa Minawi 
Reviewed by David Gutman
 
169. The Unmaking of the Arab Intellectual: Prophecy, Exile, and the Nation by Zeina G. Halabi 
Reviewed by Alexa Firat
 
174. The World in A Book: Al-Nuwayri and the Islamic Encyclopedic Tradition by Elias Muhanna
Reviewed by Matthew L. Keegan 
 

Review Essays

 
180. Empire and Capitalism in the Western Indian Ocean
by Hollian Wint
 
Slaves of One Master: Globalization and Slavery in Arabia in the Age of Empire 
by Matthew S. Hopper
 
Margins of the Market: Trafficking and Capitalism Across the Arabian Sea 
by Johan Mathew
 
Buying Time: Debt and Mobility in the Western Indian Ocean 
by Thomas F. McDow 


  • ALSO BY THIS AUTHOR

    • Now Available! Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2024 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      Now Available! Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2024 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      In this issue, we are proud to publish, “One Year Into the Genocide,” a collection of essays on an unfathomable year of genocide in Palestine, guest edited by Nour Joudah. The past year has prompted an entire spectrum of emotion, reflection, and analysis from a world coming apart at the seams. This genocide has left Palestinians reeling in new ways, grasping for expression, and treading in constant mourning at depths previously unknown.  

    • Now Available! Arab Studies Journal Announces Spring 2024 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      Now Available! Arab Studies Journal Announces Spring 2024 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      We are proud to publish this special issue as an intervention into the urgent and ongoing multidisciplinary conversation on questions of nature in the Middle East. Coordinated by guest editors Katharina Lange and Juliane Schumacher, the issue significantly expands this conversation’s regional and thematic focuses. Florian Zemmin introduces Islamic modernist conceptions of nature as an integral part of the history of global environmental thought. His article explores how Rashid Rida (1865–1935) and his intellectual circle constructed an environmental ethics within the normative matrix of the shari‘a. Thomas Kuehn calls our attention to the little-studied Province of Yemen as a critical site for the development of Ottoman environmental management. Military and technical struggles to dominate Yemeni nature were foundational to late-nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Ottoman governance in the province, and ultimately made possible the post-Ottoman Yemeni state. Emily O’Dell further expands our geographic focus to the equally understudied context of Oman. Her article explores how modern Omani poets have employed natural imagery and evocations of landscape as a means to negotiate their experience of repression and exile. Finally, Katharina Lenner and Sylvie Janssens contribute a powerful interdisciplinary interrogation of the development of environmental conservation practices in Jordan. Their analysis reveals how local and international NGOs advanced competing and intersecting conceptions of conservation, and how Jordanian communities have negotiated, resisted, and/or profited from related interventions. Separate from this special issue, our reviews section features insightful perspectives on major recent works in Ottoman and post-Ottoman history. 

    • Out Now! Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2023 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      Out Now! Arab Studies Journal Announces Fall 2023 Issue: Editors' Note and Table of Contents

      This is the Editor's Note and Table of Context for the Arab Studies Journal Fall 2023 issue, which is now available for purchase. Click here to subscribe to Arab Studies Journal.

Education in the Time of Virality

Widespread access to the internet has facilitated means of acquiring news and information at rates unseen in earlier eras. As individuals, we have the ability to post and spread political information, social commentary, and other thoughts at will. This has caused an information overload for users of social networking sites. In a fight for views, reposts, and clicks, creators, both corporate and not, have been forced to develop new tactics to inform their audiences. This response to a new mode of information consumption also forces a reconsideration of how we understand knowledge production. Much of the information put forth into the world is absorbed passively, such as through characters’ storylines in books, films, and television - and this information accumulates over a lifetime. What, then, happens when knowledge is actively consumed (as is done when reading, watching, or listening to news stories), but the manner through which the information is presented still conforms to the brevity generally associated with more passive knowledge intake?

Pew Research estimates that over 70% of Americans use their phone to read the news. This is nearly a 25% increase since 2013. The constant barrage of advertisements in online articles does not make consuming news easy to do on a phone, thereby forcing media outlets and their competitors to change and adopt new tactics. Applications such as Flipboard have tried to mitigate these frustrations by simply providing the full article without the ads on their own platform, but many people still turn to sources like The Skimm. In attempting to distill a day’s worth of news coverage on domestic affairs, foreign affairs, pop culture, and sports into a few quips, undeniably both texture and nuance are lost. To compete with these services, CNN, the New York Times, and other mainstream news sources are doing the same and producing articles that give the, “Top 5 News Moments to Start Your Day,” or a, “Daily Brief.” Of course, looking at the language differences between the New York Times daily summary versus The Skimm’s, one can tell which is a more comprehensive news source. Even so, slashing the word count still takes a toll on clearly informing the public. The question then becomes, after quickly skimming through these summaries, are people doing more readings to cover what was lost? Or has “the brief” become the new standard for knowledge production and awareness?

It is more than likely that a significant portion of The Skimm’s subscribers do go on to read the full article linked in the email, but the growing popularity of similarly quick and fast news sources has had an impact on how much information viewers and readers actually understand. Between 2011 and 2014, The Skimm was founded, along with AJ+, Now This, Upworthy, and BuzzFeed News’ more serious journalism section. Undeniably, all of these sources produce and publish very important information, and make this information accessible to a larger audience. However, their production and marketing strategies hinge upon condensing very nuanced topics into videos that are, on average, only seven minutes long, as well as optimizing their materials for social media audiences. Now, it is ridiculous to expect highly textured and complicated issues to be thoroughly represented in these videos or posts. Even research based texts do not touch upon all of the complexities of a topic. The problems arise when looking at how viewers perceive themselves and their level of knowledge after actively searching out the products of, for example, AJ+ and Buzzfeed, for information. Carefully refining their materials to fit the shortened attention span of people scrolling through Facebook, social media news organizations have found their niche audience. Their products provide a simple way to deliver information to those who want gather knowledge on the “hot topics of today,” but do not what to do the leg work to be truly informed. These videos are spread throughout Facebook, Twitter, and other social media platforms in a manner that says, “Watch this, and you will know what is going on in the world.”

Understanding how information is being pushed out into the world is almost as important as the content of the information. None of these outlets claim to provide comprehensive knowledge, but in being popular sites for information, the question becomes: do they have a responsibility to encourage their viewers to continue to inform themselves about these issues? Having a well-informed society is phenomenal, but if in informing society we are also forever altering how we consume knowledge to favor brevity over nuance, what consequences could come with this change? We must ensure that the consumption of these videos does not become a license for people to see themselves as truly informed and thus appropriate for them to take the microphones at protests and speak over those who have a solid and textured understanding of the issues. Information content is incredibly important, as is spreading knowledge, and AJ+, Now This, and the like have become important role models in showing how issues should be accessible to everyone and not clouted in jargon. But we must simultaneously consider the unintended side effects that these styles of videos have on knowledge production. Ultimately, it is a mutual effort. Just as producers must be watchful of their content and method of dissemination, we as consumers must be mindful of how we digest and understand the news we take in.


[This article was published originally Tadween`s Al-Diwan blog by Diwan`s editor, Mekarem Eljamal.]