From the Editors
Contesting Narratives, Locating Power (Lund Conference)
Challenges and Tradeoffs in Moving Beyond Dominant Approaches to the Study of the Comparative Politics of the Middle East
The recent uprisings in the Arab world have raised some tough theoretical and empirical challenges for scholars of comparative politics. The failure of dominant approaches to the study of “nondemocratic politics” to account for the breakdown of (what was previously deemed durable) authoritarian institutions, as well as the emergence of new forms of political activism outside of orthodox political channels, highlights the urgent need to move beyond conventional paradigms and theories in building and enhancing public understanding of the political realities in the Arab world. The emphasis on regime-type questions in the study of the comparative politics of the Arab world, whether democratization or authoritarian durability and governance, has crowded out important issues that speak to pressing problems and concerns in the region, such as the deepening of socio-economic inequalities and the impact of innovations in media and communication technology on political participation and public debates.
Despite their shortcomings, these paradigms continue to dominate public discourse and to inform policies of important international actors – a reality that underscores the need to challenge the validity of these approaches and their applicability to the Arab context in academic and public fora. For example, international actors continue to pursue policies that assume that economic development grounded in the principles of neo-classical economics could in fact advance meaningful democratic change and economic empowerment of unprivileged social groups in the Arab world. Resources and efforts continue to be spent on advancing projects and policies predicated on the notion that limited electoral competition under authoritarian settings could provide a viable vehicle for the gradual democratization of autocratic regimes through expanding political participation and competition. This paper develops an understanding of the tradeoff between moving beyond dominant, yet empirically tenuous, theoretical frameworks with a view to studying the political realities of the Arab world on their own terms, and the goal of assessing (if not challenging) dominant assumptions about the workings of political development in the Arab world. The two goals, though competing, are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Balancing between these two sets of objectives demands a creative strategy that combines an inductive approach to understanding Arab politics and all its nuances with a deductive strategy aimed at reevaluating conventional assumptions that often guide public understanding of Arab politics.
Jad NavigationView Full Map, Topics, and Countries »
"I wondered why anyone mourning the death of these victims would thank a negligent state that has failed to provide minimal protection for this church and over fifty others across Egypt... Perhaps religious leaders are not really men of God, but men of state."click | email | tweet
Jadalicious / جدلشس
RT @MARYAMALKHAWAJA: Overheard guards saying they are going to deport me. They keep saying I am not a citizen, but won't show me any docume…
yesterday at 8:17 PM
RT @MARYAMALKHAWAJA: I'm denied entry. I'm starting a water-only hunger strike. I won't voluntarily leave. My only demand is to be let into…
yesterday at 8:16 PM
RT @MARYAMALKHAWAJA: I'm being detained in airport. Telling me I don't have Bahraini citizenship. I'm asking for proof.
yesterday at 8:16 PM
Message From Human Rights Defender Maryam Alkhawaja http://t.co/k5VUAS3Mlr
yesterday at 7:48 PM
Open Letter on Gaza and BDS from the Middle East Caucus of the Society for Cinema and Media Studies http://t.co/OMwnsGTx7u
yesterday at 12:24 PM
Latest EntriesView All Entries »
- Message From Human Rights Defender Maryam al-Khawaja
- Beard Phobia
- نفس الكتاب".. جرحٌ تعجز الكتابة عن لَأْمِه"
- On the Margins Roundup (August)
- Prominent Human Rights Lawyer Ahmed Seif al-Islam Dies
- An Open Letter
- New Texts Out Now: Erin Runions, The Babylon Complex: Theopolitical Fantasies of War, Sex, and Sovereignty
- Arabian Peninsula Media Roundup (August 26)
- الخطر السياسي القادم ما بعد العدوان على غزة
- ملف من الأرشيف: محمد شكري
- Syria Media Roundup (August 15)
- Antisemitism and Salaita
- Israel's "Operation Status Quo": A Preliminary Assessment
- Who Are the Insurgents and Counterinsurgents?
- Support for Steven Salaita and the UIUC Boycott Continues to Grow
- Last Week on Jadaliyya (August 18-24)
- لا تقصص رؤياك
- Badr Shakir Al-Sayyab: A Profile from the Archives
- O.I.L. Media Roundup (24 August)
- منام الطفل السنجاريّ