Randa Tawil, Race in Transit: Tracing the Politics of Migration from Ottoman Syria through US Empire (Stanford University Press, 2026).
Jadaliyya (J): What made you write this book?
Randa Tawil (RT): As a scholar trained in American studies, I was interested in understanding the way that race was mapped on to Syrians traveling through the United States at the turn of the twentieth century, a time when the concept of race was being contested and codified in daily life. I also wanted to decenter the United States from the study of race and migrants. Generally, projects around race in the United States reinforce a spatial analysis which I found not really relevant for people from Ottoman Syria, whose lives were often defined by overlapping empires that interacted with local and national formations of race in the United States.
J: What particular topics, issues, and literatures does the book address?
RT: My book has two main contentions. The first concerns the migration infrastructures being assembled in the early-twentieth century to regulate migration and facilitate and police the movement of people. I argue that these shipping companies, ticketing agencies, universities, kinship networks, health inspections, and border police created the conditions in which migrants were later judged at their ports of arrival. Migration infrastructures were coordinated and installed through interimperial cooperation and competition and thus were part of a global imperial structure that regulated who could travel where and for what reason. The emerging categories of race, gender, and Syrian racial formation in the United States were part of a scattered global project invested in containing colonized people. Simply put, migration emerged not as an event but as a structure of imperialism.
In my research, I also discovered the importance of gender and sexuality in the racial formation of Syrians as they traveled. Ottoman Syria was not a monolith, and a small group of Syrian Christian men gained power and capital in cities across the region and, by the early-twentieth century, self-consciously formed their own “third class” of educated bourgeoisie and capitalists who saw themselves as distinct from rural Muslim Syrians. These men who traveled to the United States were immensely concerned with being accepted as white citizens and used their masculinity, Christianity, and education to align themselves with US imperial Christian patriarchy and to become, in effect, precariously white.
Some Syrian Christian men actively policed the movement of their poor, Muslim, female compatriots in hopes of maintaining their own place within the boundaries of whiteness. Single female travelers were seen as particularly threatening to Syrians’ status as white, and Syrian women migrants simultaneously navigated a patriarchal Western migration system and their own community’s patriarchal authority. Examining the experiences of Syrians in transit demonstrates that whiteness is an exclusionary construct based on strict hierarchies that are enforced through gender and class policing within social groups, ultimately harming the most vulnerable.
J: How does this book connect to and/or depart from your previous work?
RT: The book is a culmination of my research and earlier articles on the early Syrian diaspora living and traveling through US empire. While my other works focused on a few individuals and their trajectories, my book expands on the geography of Syrian mobilities in Europe and the Americas, retracing Syrian migrants’ mobility through Marseille, Liverpool, the Philippines, Mexico, and the United States. In this way, I have been able to make a stronger argument about the productive nature of transit across the world, and the way colonial powers worked together to create infrastructures that prohibited or permitted movement.
J: Who do you hope will read this book, and what sort of impact would you like it to have?
RT: I hope that any curious person will read my book, and anyone interested in race, migration, and/or the Syrian diaspora. I tried to write it in a way that could appeal to a broad audience by focusing on the stories of individual migrant itineraries, whose lives on the move were at times harrowing, angering, and exciting.
I would be honored if members of the Arab American diaspora read my book, particularly those descended from early Syrian migrants. What kept me writing the book, which was a long and arduous process, was the idea of bringing these early Syrian migrants to life, and having people not only learn about them, but learn from them as agents of history.
J: What other projects are you working on now?
RT: ,I am slowly going back into the library after a summer off, but I have some projects on my mind. I am interested in exploring how al-Nakba was experienced by Arabs in the United States. How did it affect Palestinian-American landholdings? How did it affect families? Did they organize? I am in the very beginnings of research, so we will see where it takes me!
J: What kinds of methods did you use to research people who were largely transient?
RT: The archive can often present a trap. I often found the subjects that I write about in police reports that condemn and exclude them, so it was really important to me to not reproduce the violence or the narrative of the archives.
One of the ways I tried to counter this was to read across archives. National archives ultimately tell the story of the nation, and they tell it in a way that seems finite and authoritative. One way to challenge this authority is to use multiple archives from different countries. The French archive will tell a different story than the American, and that difference helps us challenge both archives’ presentation of authority.
I also draw on the work of Black feminist scholars who have come up with creative and effective methods for writing about people whose only traces in the archive criminalize them. Instead of focusing on the erasure of migrants’ voices, they use speculation as a tool to open possibilities that give that silence a form and a texture. Speculation allows us to think through both positive objects of history and the matters that are absent precisely because of the methodological limits of history. Speculation is part of an ethics of historical writing that views positivist history as dependent on the silences it is built on. Historically grounded speculation can attend to the desires of migrant bodies in limbo and appreciate how they maneuvered through the conditions and constraints placed on them. Like games of chance, evidence of their choices and actions indicates only one of many possibilities. Speculation allows us a closer glimpse of the world of the migrant, and it recognizes the impossibility of knowing migrants through police documentation.
Excerpt from the book (from the Introduction, pages 1 to 4)
Habib Issa and his brother Farra had no idea how they ended up in jail in Tampico, Mexico. They had left Beirut in the spring of 1912 with the intention of going to Philadelphia to look for work. They first landed in Marseille, France, a common stopover on the way to the United States, and checked into a hotel for Syrian migrants where they hoped to stay a few nights before the next leg of their journey. On their arrival, the Syrian hotel owner explained that ships to Philadelphia only embarked from Liverpool, England. Undeterred, the brothers continued to Liverpool, where they arranged to stay with a colleague of the Syrian hotel owner in Marseille. The Issa brothers took a train, then a boat, then another train to the English port city, spending most of their savings. They arrived in Liverpool only to learn from the Syrian hotel owner there that they needed to go to Hamburg, Germany, to board a ship to Philadelphia. Believing they had no other options, the brothers traveled to Hamburg, where they finally boarded a ship out of Europe. They quickly realized that they had been placed on a cargo ship. They spent the next forty-nine days crossing the Atlantic before arriving in Tampico, Mexico, where they were arrested without explanation, imprisoned for six weeks, and deported back to Liverpool.
Stranded and penniless in Liverpool, Habib and Farra wanted justice. They formally accused Raphael Elias, the Syrian hotel owner in Liverpool who had sold them their tickets for the transatlantic voyage, of smuggling them onto a cargo ship without their knowledge and pocketing the brothers’ money.The brothers were all but laughed out of the Liverpool courtroom during the trial. The judge found their story ludicrous and joked about their ordeal: “I suppose a ticket to Philadelphia is a passport to the gaols,” he quipped to the jury’s amusement. Elias, on the other hand, was treated with a respect that bordered on reverence. The judge remarked on his university education in Paris; reporters in the press noted his freshly pressed suits, nicely groomed quaff, and perfect English. The brother’s case was dismissed. Elias continued to live and work in Liverpool, while the Issa brothers were issued a deportation notice for Beirut, where they faced an uncertain future.
If Habib and Farra had attempted to migrate to Philadelphia again, they most likely would have been turned away by inspectors at their US port of entry. The US special immigration inspector assigned to England, John Whipley, had documented the brothers’ ordeal in Mexico and trial in Liverpool and included it as an example within an extensive report on the dangers posed by Syrians who traveled through Liverpool to the United States. Whipley was convinced that the brothers went to Mexico because they could not pass the health inspection required to enter the United States. Their case became part of an arsenal of knowledge compiled by immigration inspectors like Whipley who were sent all over the world to study migrants on their way to the United States. The US government labeled the brothers unfit to enter the country and used their case as evidence that Syrians were traveling through Liverpool in order to sneak into the United States undetected. The US Commissioner General of Immigration Daniel Keefe viewed the Issa brothers’ circuitous route through the ports of Beirut, Marseille, Liverpool, Hamburg, Tampico, and back to Liverpool, as well as their subsequent failed court case, as proof enough that all Syrians were unfit for entry to the United States yet pathologically determined to enter by any means necessary.
Elias faced a markedly different fate in Liverpool. Keefe was aware of his activities and had documented cases of him swindling Syrian travelers on their way to the Americas. Yet because they had no jurisdiction in England, the US police could do little to stop him. Canadian immigration authorities and French police had also made complaints about Elias, but they ran into the same issue as the United States. In contrast to these largely powerless outside authorities, the British police in Liverpool viewed Elias as providing a service to the city by temporarily housing migrants in transit and sending them on their way as quickly as possible. They liked having Elias in town: He took care of the migrants and, if he did cause harm, it was only to a migrant community that the city detested. The local police’s view explains why he was treated with far more respect than the Issa brothers during his trial. The judge agreed with Elias’s defense that the Issa brothers were part of a larger scheme to hurt his business and upend the fragile system that ushered migrants from Liverpool to the Americas. Elias’s relationship to the British and his French education reinforced the differences between him and the Issa brothers and added to the power relations the brothers were forced to navigate as they traveled.
The brothers’ and Elias’s different relations to imperial and state power contributed to and reinforced the brothers’ exclusion from the United States. Indeed, each leg of the brothers’ journey was steeped in different assemblages of power relations that dictated their movement and its outcome. Far from being a prelude to their encounter with a new nation state, their transit shows the scattered and contextual power relations that can facilitate or prevent people from ever arriving anywhere. Habib and Farra’s ordeal seems extraordinary, but it was not all that unique. Migrants were regularly stranded, swindled, surveilled, and policed as they moved through ports toward the Americas. Their stories of disrupted transit, however, are often omitted or treated as a side note in histories of migration. The brothers’ story does not fit easily with many histories of migration: After all, they never successfully migrated anywhere. They did not make it to a US border nor did they formally meet with a US inspector in Europe or Mexico. Even the typical language of migration does not readily apply to the brothers’ experience: Were they ever immigrants? Emigrants?
The brothers’ experience demonstrates how nationally framed histories of migration can naturalize the category of the state and migrants’ lives within it, rather than historicize and challenge those boundaries. This book takes a different approach. What if we followed the way that migrants encounter states, instead of waiting at states’ borders for migrants to arrive? What could we learn about the ways race, gender, and sexuality are constructed and made meaningful in the lives of migrants if we unmoored their social formations from national geographies? In the chapters that follow, I tell the story of Syrian migration to and through US empire by examining the time migrants spend in transit zones, borderlands, and imperial outposts—that is, the moments that make visible the contextual, contingent nature of mobility. Paying attention to such moments reveals the ways in which emerging categories of social difference structure migrants’ journeys and inform how colonizers and the colonized negotiate their relationships with one another.