Golnar Nikpour, The Incarcerated Modern: Prisons and Public Life in Iran (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 2024)
[This review was originally published in the Fall 2026 issue of Arab Studies Journal. For more information on the issue, or to subscribe to ASJ, click here.]
In June 2025, the United States and Israel launched what became known as the “twelve-day war” with Iran. Almost immediately, political commentators like Michael Rubin advocated for Israel to bomb Evin prison, the infamous center for incarcerating political prisoners. In an op-ed published on the Middle East Forum (https://www.meforum.org/mef-observer/israel-should-bomb-irans-evin-prison), he wrote “the smoldering ruins of Evin would be a moment Iranians would not forget and would celebrate for decades.” Less than a week later, Israel heeded these calls and bombed the notorious prison complex. The attack did not close the carceral center, but the bombings did kill at least seventy-nine people. Evin is still in operation today. Along with the rest of Iran’s carceral system, Evin is not only manipulated in the field of war, but it has also been central to Iran’s public life and global standing.
Golnar Nikpour’s The Incarcerated Modern: Prisons and Public Life in Iran tackles Iran’s carceral system, its centrality in modern Iranian history, and its reverberations worldwide. Nikpour opens her book with an understatement: “Prisons in Iran have an unhappy global reputation” (1). The unhappiness is not unwarranted, nor is it unique to Iran. Therein lies the strength of Nikpour’s book: not only does she tell the story of carcerality in Iran, but she also does so on a global scale, highlighting the connections that crisscross transnational lines, the ironies, failures, and hypocrisies that have made prisons. Nikpour offers both a macro and micro view of incarceration that ranges from describing the Tehrani prison slang documented by Ahmad Shamlu to tracing the global pathways toward abolition. The Incarcerated Modern narrates the history of incarceration, starting in the nineteenth century, and demonstrates how the development of the prison has haunted Iran while shaping the meaning of the public in the country. Nikpour’s expansive research and deep attention to detail reflect the rigor and care with which she approached this history, as she weaves together archival sources, newspaper articles, pamphlets, memoirs, consular papers, televised trial transcripts, political cartoons, vinyl records, and other texts in an impressive and massive gathering of sources. The result is textured writing that comes to life with stunning vignettes and rich imagery, a history that is rooted in the past but calls for a liberated future.
Throughout her book, Nikpour makes two critical arguments. First, the Iranian carceral system is neither isolated nor exceptional in its operations. Second, all incarceration is unethical. Consider this striking revelation from Nikpour’s introduction: “Several prisons in the contemporary Islamic Republic, including two maximum-security prisons in Shiraz and Mashhad, were built in the 1960s from blueprints of the USP Marion in Illinois, now a part of the US federal supermax system” (11). Prisons in Iran and the US are intertwined. Iran was not alone in copying US prison designs. Beyond Iran, the Marion Penitentiary shares its structure with prisons in Israel, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom. Not only are the structures similar on a global scale, but the push toward mass incarceration also developed at an international level. As Nikpour shows, the US trained members of Iran’s secret police, SAVAK, and exported the criminalization of narcotics to Iran in the 1960s. Nikpour notes that Mohammad Reza Shah’s chief of police, Mohsen Mobasser, reported on the “great success” of these trainings, which would enable the Iranian state to ramp up the “war on narcotics” (87). These policies would result in the convergence of the War on Drugs in the 1980s in both the US and Iran at the height of mutual hostility under Ronald Reagan and Ayatollah Khomeini. In both countries, drugs were used to justify carceral expansion, which has structured their systems of incarceration. The dramatic rise in rates of incarceration has most affected those at the margins of society in each country. And yet, despite these similarities, Nikpour argues, Iran’s carceral system is often discussed in isolation, without transnational comparisons or relevant context.
Contrary to much of the literature on the history of prisons in modern Iran, Nikpour places common-law prisoners and political prisoners together in her analysis, viewing the social history of prisons and their fallout in Iran through a broader social and global lens. Nikpour draws on critical prison studies and Black feminist literature, including writings by Angela Davis, Ruth Wilson Gilmore, and Mariame Kaba. This methodological approach rejects any binary opposition between “political” prisoners and “criminals.” Instead, Nikpour shows that all forms of incarceration are political and unethical. As such, her book is distinguished as one that is not only looking at the history of Iran, but as one that looks globally toward the possibilities of abolition. Her account spans two centuries of history, offering a comprehensive history that is not limited to a single period, whether that is under the Qajars, the Pahlavis, or the Islamic Republic. Instead, Nikpour shows the continuity of these structures under different forms of governance, highlighting how each new government took on and adapted to the existing structures of incarceration toward their own interests.
Nikpour’s Incarcerated Modern is organized chronologically into six chapters that each focus on how the political moment structured and framed the social processes, intellectual debates, and material circumstances of incarceration. In the first chapter, “Lawlessness and Order,” Nikpour begins in late Qajar Iran, where narratives about crime and punishment elicited a paradox that has framed much of Qajar historiography: was the governing power strong or weak? Did the Qajars crack down on crime with menacing authority or were they barely able to keep their subjects safe? Nikpour explores these questions while also tracing how and why imprisonment became connected to notions of modernity and social reform. The second chapter, “The Criminal is the Patient, the Prison will be the Cure,” moves into the Pahlavi era and the centralization of the state’s legal and judicial system. It was in this period, under Mohammad Reza Shah, that Iran’s prison system expanded under the guidance of US advisers. The rapid growth of the carceral system, and with it, political imprisonment and the use of torture against dissidents, begot a narrative that incarceration would solve social problems.
In “Like a Fertile Storm,” the third chapter, Nikpour continues her study of the Pahlavi period, shifting her attention to opposition groups that focused on the Shah’s carceral system as the major reason for overthrowing him. Chapter 4, “The Iranian Prison Goes Global,” looks at the transnational movement of human rights activists who made Iran’s use of torture known worldwide. Nikpour notes the strange bedfellows from different ends of the political spectrum who came together in advertising and rallying against Iran’s use of torture at this time. She also highlights an irony here: the language of “human rights” was championed by none other than Princess Ashraf, the sister of Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. It was partly because of her advocacy for human rights that it became a rhetorical sledgehammer used against Pahlavi rule. Chapter 5, “Making an Example,” focuses on the revolutionary period after 1979. Nikpour makes the case that the carceral system under the Islamic Republic did not represent an aberration or a break from the past, but rather a continuation, while reflecting aspects of a new government ideology under Khomeini and other key political characters. The final core chapter, “Carcerality beyond Prisons?” discusses the adoption of global technology and expansion of structures to extend the reach of government surveillance and punishment beyond the walls of the built prison complexes.
Nikpour’s The Incarcerated Modern responds to the urgency of understanding how carcerality is not limited to the goings-on within a prison’s walls, but rather seeps into society and shapes the public sphere. It is with Nikpour’s book that we can understand how and why a prison system can spur calls for revolution and war. Contrary to what hawkish commentators have written, the wars in Iran—both in 2025 and 2026—have not resulted in the closure of Evin or any other prison structure. And while pundits advocating for the closure of a prison system may sound like abolitionists, true abolition will only be found beyond war, not through it. Nikpour closes her book by saying she wrote because of a belief that “to understand the historical origins of the modern prison in Iran is to be able to imagine a world beyond the prison as well” (224). The Incarcerated Modern offers exactly that.