Ella Fratantuono, Governing Migration in the Late Ottoman Empire (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2024)
[This review was originally published in the Fall 2026 issue of Arab Studies Journal. For more information on the issue, or to subscribe to ASJ, click here.]
“Where are you from?” or “Memleket nere?” in colloquial Turkish, is perhaps the most common question for initiating small talk in Turkey. Millions of people answer this ubiquitous inquiry by responding they are from Istanbul, only to be met with an incredulous look and a repeat question with an emphasis: “Where are you really from?” This follow-up unsettles no one, so long as they are cognizant of how a history of migration shaped modern Turkey, a history firmly rooted in the final century of the Ottoman Empire. The added emphasis gives away the knowledge that only a small segment of Istanbul’s residents can trace back their presence in the city for several generations. The main reason is the two large-scale movements of migrants that ran in opposite directions during the twentieth century: the forced departure of tens of thousands of non-Muslim Istanbulites, and the internal migration from Anatolian towns and villages in search of a better life in a city imagined to be the land of plenty. In late Ottoman times, the question “where are you reallyfrom?” would have also been pertinent in a much broader area, stretching from Albania to Libya.
Ella Fratantuono’s Governing Migration in the Late Ottoman Empire tells the story of transformations that the Ottoman Empire underwent as it devised novel mechanisms of governance to absorb millions of people who had left their homelands behind. Covering the fateful period from the 1850s to the 1910s, this brilliant book demonstrates how migrants and migration remade the empire. From the Crimean War (1853-56) to the Balkan Wars (1912-13), roughly five million individuals, most of them Muslims from the greater Black Sea region, Rumelia, and Crete, arrived in the Ottoman Empire. Rather than framing her main research question along the binary opposition of migrants and refugees, which asks why people moved, Fratantuono focuses on the visions these individuals offered for “Ottoman reform and state-building in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries” (6). The resulting narrative is rich, nuanced, and dynamic. It portrays an empire that, while shrinking physically, expanded institutionally through novel regulations and administrative departments designed to manage the arriving masses. If migrants helped shape Ottoman governance, the state strove to mold them into ideal subjects through social engineering projects. The way that migration and state-making reinforced each other stands as one of the book’s major contributions. Imperial authorities strategically settled newcomers in various locations to serve such vital functions as enhancing agricultural productivity, increasing tax revenues, and counteracting recalcitrant nomadic groups. As the state sought to cast the newcomers into industrious, loyal subjects, it envisaged that they would “breathe new life into the Ottoman economy and strengthen Ottoman sovereignty” (238).
The book’s narrative begins in the 1850s, a period that marked the empire’s first official attempts at drawing enterprising migrants to its vast, underpopulated lands. If readers of Ottoman history are more familiar with the officers, engineers, and doctors whom the imperial government invited from Europe during this era, Fratantuono shifts focus to state projects to bring in skilled and productive migrants from the continent. In the extensive historiography of the Tanzimat, scholars have generally highlighted three key events: the promulgation of the Reform Edict (Islahat Fermanı) that transformed the position of non-Muslims in the empire; the Congress of Paris that cautiously admitted the Ottomans into the Concert of Europe; and the issuing of the Land Code (Arazi Kanunnamesi) that formalized ownership with a view to consolidating government revenues and control of land. Fratantuono proposes a refreshing look at the eventful 1850s by foregrounding migrants and migration. In this regard, a major piece of legislation, the Migration Regulation (Muhaceret Nizamnamesi) of 1857 is analyzed as the Ottoman response to the global migration boom in the middle of the nineteenth century. By so issuing this reform to incentivize settlement and promote farming, the Ottomans aligned with other states such as Russia, the United States, and Brazil, which had already begun to devise land grant programs, loans, and tax benefits for agricultural colonists. The best-laid plans came apart at the seams, however, as major wars erupted in the greater Black Sea region. Instead of self-sufficient agricultural colonists from across Europe, unexpectedly high numbers of dispossessed individuals in need of shelter and financial assistance arrived in the Ottoman Empire.
In a familiar periodization of Ottoman history, the Hamidian era is framed in stark contrast to the Tanzimat period. Although these two epochs differ from each other in notable ways, they share more commonalities than generally acknowledged. One of Fratantuono’s remarkable achievements is the insightful juxtaposition of these two periods in terms of migration policies. The book’s narrative suggests both continuities and shifts in the Ottoman state’s approach to the mass movement of migrants over the course of sixty years. A turning point came with the Treaty of Berlin (1878), which led to major alterations in the demographic composition of the empire. The ratio between Muslims and Christians underwent a substantial change in favor of the former. If the year 1878 effected a significant quantitative change, the ensuing period brought about a qualitative shift in Ottoman governance, especially in eastern Anatolia, Macedonia, and Crete. Drawing explicit connections between reform, European supervision, and communal rights of various Christian populations, the Treaty of Berlin further politicized religion and ethnicity in the Ottoman Empire. Accordingly, in the settlement policies of the Hamidian officials, “religion and ethnicity were factors in their determination of how populations could serve their visions of reform” (185). If such heightened sensitivity distinguishes Hamidian statecraft from early Tanzimat governance, the continued emphasis on producing industrious subjects through population distribution (religiously diverse in the 1850s, almost exclusively Muslim in the 1890s) as a strategy for preserving Ottoman sovereignty bridges the historiographical chasm between the two periods.
Fratantuono’s examination of Hamidian-era Muslim immigration underscores the state’s intensifying focus on subjecthood and sovereignty after 1878. This analytical framework sidesteps the timeworn perspective of pan-Islamism that has long dominated scholarship on the Hamidian era. During this period, the official encouragement of Muslim immigration went hand in hand with renewed vigilance regarding cross-border mobility, attempts at preventing Armenian return migration in the early 1890s, and heightened sensitivity to the nationality of non-Ottoman Muslim pilgrims in the Hejaz. Fratantuono analyzes Ottoman approaches to mobility as part of a global pattern of preferential migration. The Ottoman story elucidates the general contours of the late nineteenth-century world, which saw both increased transnational migration and state attempts to curtail the movement of certain ethnic or religious groups (for example the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 in the United States or the Russian Empire’s sporadic bans of Muslim pilgrimage to the Ottoman Empire).
In six chapters organized both chronologically and thematically, Fratantuono traces the evolving meanings of the word muhacir, a capacious label that corresponded to multiple, and at times intersecting, categories across time and space, such as European agricultural colonists, civilians fleeing wars (including Christians and Jews), and exclusively Muslim migrants. Studies of mass migration often rely on aggregated numbers and collective experiences, obscuring individual stories. Sometimes it is hard to avoid doing so, as the archival documents may put categories over personalities, especially if they were written amid movements of overwhelming migration, as was often the case in the Ottoman nineteenth century. In Fratantuono’s book, however, the reader catches glimpses of state officials in charge of governing migration and hears echoes of migrants preserved in the Ottoman archives and in print. Such robust research showcases stories of a rich cast of historical actors that includes African Americans who inquired about the possibility of establishing cotton growing colonies in the Ottoman Empire (Chapter 1: Muhacir as Colonist); Nusret Pasha who created a map of Rumelia as an essential tool for migrant settlement and overall administration (Chapter 2: Muhacir as Problem); a badly wounded refugee named Elif whose photograph was featured in an album to visualize and instrumentalize the atrocities of the 1877-78 war (Chapter 3: Muhacir as Victim); Muzaffer Pasha who surveyed land and composed a register, contributing to a documentary regime aspiring to regulate the settlement of migrants and the behavior of the overall population (Chapter 4: Muhacir as Failure); Commissioner Ahmed, a member of the Migrant Settlement Committee in the Ankara province, who championed Muslim settlement in the region to curtail Christian supremacy in commerce (Chapter 5: Muhacir as Muslim); and Ahmed Şükrü, editor of the Ottoman newspaper Muhacir, who was a vocal dissenter in the heated immigration debates of the early twentieth century about whether Muslims living under Christian rule had a religious obligation to emigrate (Chapter 6: Muhacir as Possibility).
These chapters trace the multivalence of the term muhacir for imperial officials and shine light on various aspects of Ottoman statecraft that expanded in tandem with new subjects entering the sultan’s well-protected domains. In post-Ottoman Turkey, over the course of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first, the label of muhacir gave way to mülteci (used mostly for those fleeing war and conflict) and göçmen (a much more capacious term encompassing nearly all forms of domestic and cross-border movement). Slowly but steadily, muhacir fell out of use though it preserved its potency especially with its pejorative connotation of foreignness in the vernacular. Like the empire itself, the word disintegrated but never disappeared. As Fratantuono concludes, “the meanings attached to those terms continue to shape practices of inclusion and exclusion around the world, including within the Ottoman successor states” (247).