Celebrating the Two-Year Anniversary of Jadaliyya’s Environment Page Launch

The Nile at Aswan. Photo by Ibrahim El-Mezayen via Wikimedia Commons. The Nile at Aswan. Photo by Ibrahim El-Mezayen via Wikimedia Commons.

Celebrating the Two-Year Anniversary of Jadaliyya’s Environment Page Launch

By : Environment Page Editors

The Jadaliyya Environment page started with several unconnected conversations which all came together two years ago, during the early months of the pandemic. It’s almost hard to remember at this point, but a lot of us were feeling like we needed something to doand the pandemic had made us all even more acutely aware than normal of our bodies and the lost material sensation of daily life.

We launched on Earth Day 2020 with a bouquet of stories and a mission statement that emphasized the need for critical perspectives which did not treat the environment as an apolitical question. This year, we published seventeen storiesboth written work and podcastsin both English and Arabic, focusing on themes of race and the environment; climate change and disasters; scarcity narratives; the built environment; and environmental knowledge-production.

Following up on last year’s one-year anniversary post, we’ve prepared the following post to share everything we’ve published in the past year. We hope these resources will be useful for researchers; all who are looking to learn more about environmental questions in the region; and those in search of teaching materials that critically engage with these topics.

Thank you to all of our readers, listeners, and viewers for supporting the page over the past two years! You can reach our editorial team at environment@jadaliyya.com with questions or ideas about how to contribute, and we continue to welcome submissions to the page.

We are opening by highlighting a few pieces published this year that generated important new conversations and contributions. 

Spotlight on Selected 2021-22 New Pieces


Alix Chaplain, Strategies of Power and the Emergence of Hybrid Mini-Grids in Lebanon

From our editors: “In this extraordinary piece, Chaplain traces the emergence of collective electrical supply systems in villages in Lebanon’s Bekaa valley. Deeply researched and analytically innovative, this piece explores the tensions between viewing these mini-grids as essential services in the context of the overall breakdown of the Lebanese state, but also as fundamentally political technologies that reflect and intensify structural inequalities.”

 عمر امسيح تسدال، ويسرى عثمان، وماري دعيق، وحنان زهران، وتالا خوري، وفؤاد معدي، وسمير خريشة، وساهر الخوري، ويارا دواني، وإياد طعم الله, مكانيات: طريقة مفتوحة ومتأصلة لدراسة المشهد الطبيعي

From our editors: “This piece outlines the research approach and critical resources of Makaneyyat, a Palestinian research collective that works to strengthen agro-ecological landscapes in Palestine. The authors describe the array of field-based, geospatial, and qualitative methods, such as oral history, that they have drawn on to produce Makaneyyat’s agro-ecological research engine and broader approach to studying and supporting communities of plants and people in Palestine. Their work provides a model and theoretical framework for developing collaborative, community-based research and tools to support farmers and communities in Palestine and the broader region in the face of climate change and Israeli colonialism.”

Bayan Abubakr, The Contradictions of Afro-Arab Solidarity(ies): The Aswan High Dam and the Erasure of the Global Black Experience

From our editors: “This important piece traces a new environmental history of race in Egypt, showing how even as the Aswan Dam became a focal point of global Afro-Arab solidarities, it was predicated materially on Nubian displacement and discursively on the erasure of Black bodies from the “modern” Egyptian nation. In focusing on how multiple axes of power intersected around the Aswan Dam, Abubakr offers a fresh angle on the familiar history of hydraulic infrastructure in Egypt.”

Red, Green, and International: Abolition Geographies and Environmental Movements with Ruth Wilson Gilmore

From our editors: “This episode of the “Environment in Context” podcast is a gripping conversation between the geographer and prison abolitionist Ruth Wilson Gilmore, environment page co-editor Huma Gupta, and anthropologist China Sajadian. Gilmore relates her research on carcerality and environment through a global, comparative lens, from the long traditions of emancipation within Black Marxism, to popular struggles against land grabs in Brazil, to the contemporary challenges of giant monopsonies like Amazon. If abolition must be green, Gilmore insists, it must also be anticapitalist and internationalist.”

Full List of Pieces Published in the Last Year


NEWTON: Anny Gaul, Graham Auman Pitts, and Vicki Valosik, eds.,
Making Levantine Cuisine: Modern Foodways of the Eastern Mediterranean

Eyad Houssami, Review of Nomad’s Land: Pastoralism and French Environmental Policy in the Nineteenth-Century Mediterranean World

Jamie Fico, What Happens to Oasis Farming when the Water Runs Out?

Huma Gupta, Environmental Film Review: She Was Not Alone / لم تكن وحيدة 

Cihan Tugal, One World, In Flames, from California to Turkey

Mohamed Abo-Elgheit, Quick Thoughts: Mohamed Abo-Elgheit on Egypt and the Nile River Crisis

Owain Lawson, Crisis and Change: An Interdisciplinary Roundtable on Climate

Arbella Bet-Shlimon, Oil Contingency: Histories of Oil and Climate Change

Elizabeth Holt, Oil Sensoria

Sophia Stamatopolou-Robbins, Climate and Commensuration in Palestine

External events

  • MESA panels: The Environment page organized and sponsored two sessions at the online Middle East Studies Association conference in December 2021: “Spatial and Environmental Histories of Iraq” with Camille Cole, Huma Gupta, Kali Rubaii, Gabriel Young, and Faisal Husain; and “Critical Environmental Perspectives of the MENA” with Jeannie Sowers, Jennifer Derr, Noura Wahby, China Sajadian, Gabi Kirk, and Owain Lawson.

Announcements:


Announcing NYU Hagop-Kevorkian Center 2021-2022 Virtual Series: Elements of Border and Infrastructure

Media Roundups:


Extended Media Roundup (March-April 2021)

Extended Media Roundup (May-June 2021)

  • ALSO BY THIS AUTHOR

    • Environment and Climate Panels at the 2024 MESA Annual Meeting

      Environment and Climate Panels at the 2024 MESA Annual Meeting

      The Jadaliyya environment page editors are pleased to feature these panels and roundtables focused on environment and climate at the 2024 Middle East Studies Association Annual Meeting (MESA). MESA 2024 will be held virtually from November 11–16.

    • Event Announcement: Food Security and Palestinian Liberatory Ecologies

      Event Announcement: Food Security and Palestinian Liberatory Ecologies

      Join a conversation between Laila el-Haddad and Michael Fakhri. Leila el-Haddad is a renowned journalist and writer and co-author of critically acclaimed The Gaza Kitchen: A Palestinian Culinary Journey (2013). She brings with her a wealth of experience and knowledge about Palestinian foodways and their relation to cultural resistance. Dr. Michael Fakhri is the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food and professor at the University of Oregon School of Law. He recently authored a 2024 UN report “Starvation and the right to food, with an emphasis on the Palestinian people’s food sovereignty.” Fakhri and El-Haddad will discuss the report and their respective research regarding Palestinian food, politics, and cultural resistance.

    • Roundtable on Capitalism and Climate

      Roundtable on Capitalism and Climate

      Climate change is one of the most pressing issues of our time, globally. For the most part, the Middle East and North Africa have remained marginal to global conversations around climate. Where these conversations have engaged the region, they have often rejuvenated dangerous and reductive Orientalist tropes. In the face of simplistic narratives about the Middle East as an exceptional site of environmental crisis, scholars and activists have begun to explore the complex histories and presents of environmental politics and the ecological dimensions of capitalism. This roundtable, drawing on a workshop held in October 2023, offers some new approaches – both methodological and analytical – to the intertwined problems of environment, politics, and capitalism.

Jadaliyya Launches New Environment Page

The Jadaliyya Environment Page is a forum for innovative, critical, and incisive analysis and reporting on environmental questions in the Middle East. It invites contributors and readers to rethink these questions by taking a broad stance on what counts as an environmental issue. Whereas environmental questions in the Middle East are usually framed in terms of the security of water or oil, this page purposefully seeks out a wide array of sources and perspectives in examining important environmental issues on the ground and across the region. As curators of this Jadaliyya project, we want to provide a platform that brings together diverse perspectives including, and especially, from those living in the region, indigenous voices, and grassroots approaches. We aim to gather content from a variety of academic disciplines, activists, and others working on the ground. Too often, Euro-American international institutions and white Western voices dominate—and depoliticize—the conversation on the environment. In contradistinction, we argue that we cannot just talk about water as scarcity, but we must view water access as an environmental justice issue and a human right. Instead of approaching countries in the region as exceptionally oil-dependent, we consider the politics of fossil fuels, energy transition, and climate change mitigation to be a global terrain of struggle entailing the uneven transformation of economic activities, social life, infrastructures, and environments. Similarly, we cannot just talk about environmental issues in terms of rural development and nature reserves, but must also talk about environmental well-being in cities. 

The current global crisis around COVID-19 (coronavirus) has thrown into new relief the importance of food security and health security, and of thinking explicitly about disease as an environmental phenomenon—particularly for those at the intersection of social and economic inequalities and of marginalized identities. Environmental justice movements have increasingly sprung up on the ground throughout the Middle East, and communities have connected the inequalities they face to environmental justice struggles around the world. The page will focus on the responses and solutions to global environmental issues developed by people in the region. We will include historical analyses that shed light on the ever-changing relationships between humans and their surroundings. As both the stakes of and interest in environmental questions in the Middle East grow, this page will provide a platform for activists and scholars to experiment with new approaches and to transform this conversation. We welcome comments and contributions to the new page at environment@jadaliyya.com.

The Environment Page is co-edited by Danya Al-Saleh, Camille Cole, Brittany Cook, Huma Gupta, Gabi Kirk, Carly KrakowOwain Lawson, Graham Auman Pitts, Malihe Razazan, and Salma Nashabe Talhouk.

Launch Articles


The Campaign to Eradicate Smallpox in Monarchic Iraq
 
by Sara Farhan and Huma Gupta

Countering Lawfare and Environmental Racism in Gaza and Palestine: The Case Study of the Jewish National Fund versus US Campaign for Palestinian Rights 
by Gabi Kirk 

Danger, Turbines! A Jawlani Cry against Green Energy Colonialism in the Occupied Syrian Golan Heights 
by Muna Dajani

Media Roundup


Environment Page Extended Media Roundup (January–March 2020)


Environment in Context: Green Sukuk - The Future of Islamic Financing for Climate Change Adaptation
 
An Interview with Aneil Tripathy by Bassam Haddad and Huma Gupta

Jadaliyya Talks: Co-Editors Go In-Depth on the New Environment Page
An Interview with Danya Al-Saleh, Brittany Cook, Huma Gupta, and Owain Lawson by Malihe Razazan